Return to Minehowe
the 2000 excavation
At the end of June 2000, four weeks of intensive
archaeological work at Minehowe drew to a close.
Although an air of mystery remained around the
ancient underground chamber, the excavation revealed evidence
of a site that was soon heralded as "the heart of Iron Age Orkney".
Although all eyes were originally on the underground
chamber, the 2000 excavations uncovered finds that categorically
answered the one question that had puzzled archaeologists since
the howe was reopened in 1999 - how old is it?
As originally expected, Minehowe turned out
to be an Iron Age construction, dating
from the middle or later years of the period, from around 200BC
to 500AD.
Of particular interest were the artefacts and evidence
found around the outside of the chamber, evidence provided the experts with a clearer understanding of various elements of
Iron Age culture.
Throughout the excavation, a more
elaborate, and fascinating, view of the area surrounding Minehowe
emerged. This showed that the underground structure was merely a small
part of what appeared to have been a prestigious and powerful Iron
Age settlement.
Lying around 300 metres from Minehowe, were the
remains of what was thought to be a broch. Were the inhabitants of the broch using the natural mound, now known as Longhowe, as a ceremonial
walkway through the water and marshlands that then surrounded their
stronghold?
The
scale of the ditch
It had originally been thought that, because of
the similarities between the Minehowe ditch and the one surrounding
the Standing Stones of Stenness,
the Tankerness site may have dated from the Neolithic period. The
dig, however, ruled this idea out and placed Minehowe and its surrounding
structures firmly in the Iron Age.
Orkney archaeologist Julie Gibson explained: "At
the beginning we didn't know if this monument was all of a piece
or whether it had possibly been a Neolithic ditch and chambered
cairn which had been reinhabited by the Iron Age people.
"However now the excavations are complete
and we have as yet no evidence of Neolithic working here at all.
That isn't to preclude the possibility but it now seems extremely
unlikely."
More information about the monument's enclosing
ditch - first revealed by geophysicist John Gater in 1999 - was
also gathered and proved particularly interesting.
Encircling the base of the howe, the 18 feet wide
ditch was found to have been dug out to a depth of around 14 feet.
The ditch surrounded Minehowe, leaving a single entrance causeway,
built up with stonework at the sides, to allow access to the monument.
Evidence
of ancient metalworking
The remains of an Iron Age roundhouse, lying beneath the remains of a later Pictish house, were found a short distance from Minehowe's entrance causeway.
Around this building, the excavators uncovered what
has so far been the biggest example of Iron Age metalworking in
Orkney.
Julie Gibson regarded the discovery of this area
as particularly significant, particularly as it might shed light
on the craft of these Iron Age metalworkers.
"We've got this great workshop interest
here." she said. "Basically we've found all the stuff
that goes with metalworking - ore, furnace bases, crucibles, moulds,
bits of metalwork and whetstones. So we've found this metalworking
area on the outside that is particularly important because all that's
been found before is the artefacts. Evidence of the creation of
these artefacts, however, is a not as common which makes this area
extremely interesting to us. Most of our material that we've got
at the moment has come out of the middens there."
"There's the sort of things you find in very
special places in brochs set
aside for metalworking but here off course we've got our broch separated
from the metalworking area and from the ritual area (Minehowe) so
I think we can maybe get some more answers about the thought that
went into metalworking. Was it regarded as an almost "magical"
process in a sense or a slightly dangerous process in this conversion
of the stone and ore into metal and art?"
"This area is going to be important as it
gives us an impression of how Iron Age people were thinking about
this metalworking process as well as what they were actually doing.
All of which is virtually unknown."
But although the evidence shows these early metalworkers
were extremely active in the area surrounding Minehowe, when it
comes to the actual quantity of the goods being produced, the experts
could only guess.
"Basically, with these buildings we've only
just scratched the surface." said Julie. "We haven't got
down into them at all. What we have done is established that they
are there and established roughly what was going on but there's
no tangible links to the structures at present."
Around
the howe
Most of the excavation work took place around
the outside of Minehowe, with only a few excursions made inside
the actual chamber.
Although it had been thought there was originally
some sort of structure over the entrance to Minehowe's chamber,
the investigations proved inconclusive.
"There doesn't appear to have been major
structures at the front as far as that trench leads us to believe,
so we haven't got that circular building with a knob on the top,
but we may have something over to one side. We're just not certain."
said Julie Gibson.
However, immediately before the entrance a curious
flat stone was found and when carefully lifted revealed a small
bowl-shaped scoop of earth. This scoop was filled with ash which
is thought might have been the remains of a cremation.
Minehowe
and the broch connection
Although the focus of the excavation was not directly
on the underground chamber, the archaeologists now have a clear
idea of the relationship between Minehowe and the other elements
found in the ancient landscape.
Julie Gibson explained: "It's quite interesting
in terms of the entire monument being a ritual area. The monument
doesn't just consist of the underground structure - the monument
consists of this great ditch and the underground structure and other
things, including the niche at the rear of the howe, the paving
and the deposition of this ashy material. Whatever this ash was
it was definitely disposed off in that way - whether it was a cremation
or the product of burning some other substance that was special
and then was deposited there."
"What we've begun to see is that Minehowe
is somehow connected to the nearby broch, which is less that 300
metres away, in that the entrance to the monument leads down towards
Longhowe and then at the other end of Longhowe you have the broch
with its external defences leading up onto the mound - so in a sense
Longhowe a path between the broch and Minehowe. This is a physical
link between the two which we didn't know about before."
Roman connections....
The discovery of artefacts with a distinctly Roman
origin - a fibula brooch, pottery fragments and glass - is also
helping the archaeologists build up a picture of how the area was
used in the Iron Age.
"What is particularly interesting about the
Roman finds is that we put in two very small ditches and out of
the one very small ditch section we've found the fibula brooch,
the glass and two or three other bits of pottery that were Roman.
Now that's quite a lot given the amount of area that we've opened
up which has the potential to produce these finds. Had we opened
more we may well have found more of these high-class trading goods."
"These Roman finds are only paralleled in
broch sites in Orkney. So what we're beginning to get is a clear
link between the broch and this site (Minehowe) - a link that is
making the explanation of these funny wells in brochs clearer as
ritual by dint of inference from this. All in all the site is extremely
important in that it is going to give us an insight into the rituals
of the Iron Age period - rituals which at the moment are not really
understood at all."
A ritual landscape?
An important result of the Minehowe excavation
was the confirmation that the Iron Age community who were reusing
a landscape that had already been used by their Bronze Age ancestors
still appeared to have some reverence for those who had gone before.
According to Julie Gibson it was clear that in
creating their ceremonial walkway across the top of Longhowe to
Minehowe, the Iron Age builders were leaving the Bronze Age cist
burials undisturbed.
She said: "We can now see that the Iron Age
builders built their causeway across the top of Longhowe through
what was previously a Bronze Age ritual landscape to an Iron Age
ritual landscape of their own."
When it came to the most important discovery of
the excavation, Julie was in no doubt.
"I think it has to be the metalworking area
- it's going to prove very exciting in the future. As objects I
can't decide between the fibula brooch and the bronze stud but I
think that it's the totality of it, the sheer enormity of the monument
that is the "star find" and its connection to the broch,
I think that's the key thing."
Focus
on the East Mainland
For Tom Muir, who grew up in the shadow of Minehowe,
the attention the site has brought to the East Mainland is well
deserved and long overdue.
"There has always been this sort of
intellectual snobbery going on from way, way back." He said.
"The West Mainland has all the really well known sites and
even as far back as the 1800s the East Mainland was being dismissed
as insignificant.
A prime example of this attitude can be found
within the pages of the Third Statistical Account that relates an
account made by the Reverend Charles Clouston of Sandwick in 1862.
In his guide to the East Mainland he states:
"The traveller may with ease ride
round all the East Mainland in the course of a day: but we have
nothing to hold out as an inducement for undertaking such a journey."
In other words, the Reverend Clouston was telling
his readers not to bother!
Tom continued: "Whereas the archaeology of
the East Mainland isn't maybe as conspicuous as the West Mainland,
with your stone circles and suchlike, there is an awful lot out
here. It usually just lying there and if it's ever been looked at,
it was just delved into by antiquarians of the nineteenth century
- much like Dingieshowe was - or more often than not its existence
was just recorded and it was left.
"The one thing that this excavation
really has done for me personally is having toured around Tankerness
and Toab with Dr Colin Richards, you start looking for the lumps
and bumps whereas before you just drove past and you never thought
about it. The amount of mounds around that area is staggering. Even
the natural glacial ones like Longhowe and the one at the back of
Kirkyard all have activity on top of them - there are either settlements
or in the case of Longhowe there's these Bronze Age cist burials."
"So this was a burial place for people in
the Bronze Age, then you have this chamber with the ditch around
it being constructed in the Iron Age as a sort of significant religious
centre of some sort but considered special. And then you had a medieval
chapel in the area and nowadays you've got the kirkyard. So local
folks still see it as a special place because it's the final resting
place of their ancestors and their families."
"It gives a nice feeling of continuity from
the Bronze Age right through to the present day that this small
area has always been set aside as somewhere a bit special." |